TECH: Super Structure (part 1) (500 words)
Mar. 9th, 2022 03:58 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Original posting Dec. 13, 2018
I recently grabbed a copy of Super Structure by James Scott Bell, and am working my way through it. Looks great, and I think I will meditate on at least some of the points he makes here on the list. So...
"the overall plot of a novel is about how a character confronts death."
Skip a little...
"Now, there are three kinds of death: physical, professional, psychological."
Aha. Okay, so the point is that stories need stakes that are high enough to really engage us, as readers. Which means death. Physical death, in some cases, like thrillers, mysteries, and others. Pretty straightforward, someone is gonna kill somebody else.
Professional death? I may lose my job, career, love of music,... or sometimes the role that we play in life? Father, spouse, something that is critical to us. A bit more abstract than physical death, but nearly as common a threat or danger.
Or psychological? Hum, losing my self image? Losing my respect? Sure... how can this person become fully themselves, and what blocks that, what can tear them down? Sure...
James gives several examples of these points, and you really should read his book. Or perhaps you could take some stories or books you like, and consider just how this plays out there.
Hum... I wonder if you could take Maslow's hierarchy of needs and play that against James's three kinds of death? Physiological needs matches up with his physical death. Safety, love/belonging, esteem? Sort of matches up with professional death? They are all about the relationship with other people and society at least. And then there's that self-actualization top of the pyramid. Psychological death? Perhaps.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs has a description...
Physiological needs? Food, water, sleep, shelter, sex… Physical things!
Safety… Covers a range of needs. Personal security, emotional security, financial security, health and well-being, avoiding accidents and illness.
Social belonging. Friendships, intimacy, family… Professional status fits right in here.
Esteem. This is probably sliding over towards psychological death. Self-esteem, self-respect, competence, mastery, and so forth?
Self-actualization. Now we are into motivation, seeking to understand sense of self, pursuing a goal, seeking happiness. Okay, that sort of lines up with psychological death.
Sorry about the little side trip, but it's an interesting thought for me. It might add some richness to your exploration of the death stakes, too?
Why is it important to decide what kind of death, and how it plays out in your story, as early as possible? Well, James suggests:
“Being able to define the type of death that overhangs your main plot will keep you on track when you write your novel. It will bring you back to the path if you happen to get lost along the way.”
Okay? So just what kind of death does your protagonist face? Physical, professional, or psychological? What will it cost if they lose, or what will they win if they succeed?
Something to consider, right?
I recently grabbed a copy of Super Structure by James Scott Bell, and am working my way through it. Looks great, and I think I will meditate on at least some of the points he makes here on the list. So...
"the overall plot of a novel is about how a character confronts death."
Skip a little...
"Now, there are three kinds of death: physical, professional, psychological."
Aha. Okay, so the point is that stories need stakes that are high enough to really engage us, as readers. Which means death. Physical death, in some cases, like thrillers, mysteries, and others. Pretty straightforward, someone is gonna kill somebody else.
Professional death? I may lose my job, career, love of music,... or sometimes the role that we play in life? Father, spouse, something that is critical to us. A bit more abstract than physical death, but nearly as common a threat or danger.
Or psychological? Hum, losing my self image? Losing my respect? Sure... how can this person become fully themselves, and what blocks that, what can tear them down? Sure...
James gives several examples of these points, and you really should read his book. Or perhaps you could take some stories or books you like, and consider just how this plays out there.
Hum... I wonder if you could take Maslow's hierarchy of needs and play that against James's three kinds of death? Physiological needs matches up with his physical death. Safety, love/belonging, esteem? Sort of matches up with professional death? They are all about the relationship with other people and society at least. And then there's that self-actualization top of the pyramid. Psychological death? Perhaps.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs has a description...
Physiological needs? Food, water, sleep, shelter, sex… Physical things!
Safety… Covers a range of needs. Personal security, emotional security, financial security, health and well-being, avoiding accidents and illness.
Social belonging. Friendships, intimacy, family… Professional status fits right in here.
Esteem. This is probably sliding over towards psychological death. Self-esteem, self-respect, competence, mastery, and so forth?
Self-actualization. Now we are into motivation, seeking to understand sense of self, pursuing a goal, seeking happiness. Okay, that sort of lines up with psychological death.
Sorry about the little side trip, but it's an interesting thought for me. It might add some richness to your exploration of the death stakes, too?
Why is it important to decide what kind of death, and how it plays out in your story, as early as possible? Well, James suggests:
“Being able to define the type of death that overhangs your main plot will keep you on track when you write your novel. It will bring you back to the path if you happen to get lost along the way.”
Okay? So just what kind of death does your protagonist face? Physical, professional, or psychological? What will it cost if they lose, or what will they win if they succeed?
Something to consider, right?