TECH: Make a Scene #11: Scene Intentions
So here we go, looking at Make a Scene by Jordan Rosenfeld. This week we're going to look at intentions among the core elements of the scene.
Let's see. Get the setting right, use the senses, develop and motivate characters, mix in some plot, don't forget the subtext, and work that dramatic tension with us wondering just how it's going to come out. And then to avoid wandering aimlessly in your narrative, make sure that the protagonist has a clear intention in every scene, something that they want to accomplish that gives purpose to the scene. Don't just roll the dice and pick one, tie it directly to the significant issues of the plot and your protagonist's back story.
Jordan points out that the intention is a character's plan to take an action or do something. Motivation, on the other hand, is the reasons that explain why the character has these plans. Intentions drive action and consequences, making the scene relevant to the plot and the characters. Intentions build drama and conflict, because as the character pursues the intentions, you as writer make sure that it is opposed, thwarted, grows in desirability, and perhaps -- at the end of the story -- allow the character to achieve it or a reasonable facsimile along with whatever satisfaction may result.
As you start to write a scene, you need to consider what the protagonist wants, needs, and intends to do. Consider the following questions:
1. What are the most immediate desires of the character?
2. When will your characters achieve their intention or meet with opposition? Intention that meets with complications builds drama and suspense. Don't let your characters achieve things too quickly or too easily.
3. Does the scene intention makes sense for your plot? Beware of tangents and side paths (do we know anyone who would be so easily distracted? :-)
4. Who will help your characters achieve their goal? Who will oppose them? Decide how the characters and conditions support or thwart your protagonist's intentions, and make sure there is enough resistance to the scene to avoid achieving intentions too soon or delaying them beyond the realistic.
Jordan recommends thinking about intentions in two ways, as plot based and as scene specific.
Plot-Based IntentionsThe first imperative for every character in every scene should tie back in some way to the significant situation of the plot. This helps to tie the scenes together. The intention is a course of action that your character plans to take or needs to take in the scene because of the significant situation -- and the consequences of actions.
Scene-Specific IntentionsAlong with the grand intentions related to the plot that push the character, there are often more immediate scene-based intentions. These are often tied to consequences -- after the car blows up, characters need to hide. They may want to run down the main street, but with the sniper busily picking people off, ducking into the sewers is a much more reasonable reaction. And so forth.
Opposition to the IntentionBut with the character's plan established and starting to go into action in the scene, opposition rears its head. Opposition builds tension, keeps the sense of urgency alive, delays achievement, and raises... dramatic tension. Jordan lists four major ways to oppose intentions:
1. Prevent the completion of the intention. Direct intervention, unexpected storms, accidents -- lots of things can get in the way, and do.
2. Throw in a twist. The protagonist learns that what he intended to do is impossible, illegal, wrong, or otherwise risky. Does the protagonist go ahead anyway, give up, or try something different?
3. Complicate the intention. The protagonist often sets out with one intention in mind, but then circumstances, information, or something else intervenes and adds additional bits and pieces to the course of action. You can't just kill the bad guy, you have to find out where the hostages are.
4. Create a new intention. When the original intention is thwarted, complicated, or twisted, the protagonist may need to change course and figure out a new intention.
Support for the IntentionAllies, assistance, the odd bit of information -- now and then your protagonist will receive some support. "Protagonists need friends and supporters, small acts of kindness, insights and clues that lead them on in their journeys."
So that's Chapter 11, the last of the core elements for scenes. There are the grand or strategic intentions driven by the plot that push the protagonist and the narrative. There are scene-specific intentions, the tactical reactions to consequences within the various scenes. And there's the opposition that builds the tension and drama by keeping your character from simply deciding to do something and doing it. For stories, characters want to do things -- and other people, the world, even their own nature instantly get in the way and keep them from simple achievement. Or to put it another way, because of the resistance, achieving their goal is heroic.
The next big chunk of the book talks about various specific types of scenes. The first scene, the suspense scene, dramatic scenes, contemplative scenes, dialogue scenes, action scenes, flashback scenes, climactic scenes, and final scenes. So you can lay out your scenic smorgasbord and feast, I guess?
Today's assignment? As usual, take a scene from a book or a scene that you've been working on. Now consider the protagonist. What is their intention in this scene? What do they want to achieve or do? Is it tied back to the original plot, or is it a reaction to some of the consequences at this point? What or who opposes them? What support do they get? Now consider whether there are ways to sharpen their intentions? Is there another intention, plot-based or scene-based, that you should include in this scene? Are the motivations pushing their intentions clear and sharp? Do you want to adjust the opposition? Take a look at this scene in terms of the intentions of the characters, and how you might tweak those.
Write? Sounds like a plan to me.
To achieve the impossible dream, follow the improbable path! And keep going.